Municipalities of Berati and Përmeti -Concept, Detail Designs and Supervision for Integrated Urban Upgrading
CONTRACT AWARD NOTICE
- Reference code
- Contract No: RFP No.: AL-ADF-31055-CS-QCBS
- Country: Albania
- Sector: Tourism Development
- Project Title: Project for Integrated Urban and Tourism Development -PIUTD
- Assignment Title: “Municipalities of Berati and Përmeti -Concept, Detail Designs and Supervision for Integrated Urban Upgrading”
- Executing Agency: Albanian Development Fund
- Publication date of the procurement notice: 05 October 2017
- Number of tenders that has submitted Expression of Interest: 29
No. |
Name of the Consulting firms |
Country |
1 |
JV Institut IGH d.d. & Urban Planning Institute of Croatia (UH) d.o.o& Taulant ltd |
Croatia/Croatia/Albania |
2 |
Association Ateleir 4 & Keios |
Albania/Italy |
3 |
JV. Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A.(TPA) ” &”Arkonstudio” ltd & “Erald- G” ltd |
Greece/Albania/Albania |
4 |
JV. “ABDR Architteti Associati”&”MetroPolis” ltd |
Italy/Albania |
5 |
JV.” Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd |
France/France/Albania |
6 |
JV. “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)”ltd |
Italy/Italy/Albania |
7 |
JV. “Hydea” spa & “UTS-01” ltd |
Italy/Albania |
8 |
Consortium “Arriola & Fiol Arquitectes”&”Studio B&L” ltd& “IC Consulten”ltd |
Spain/Albania/Albania |
9 |
JV “Iproplan@Planungsgesellschaft” & “Plan-Consult” ltd |
Germany/ Albania |
10 |
Association “XDGA- Xaveer De Geyter Architects”, Belgium &” Symbiotica ”Albania & Germany&”Infrakonsult ” Albania and “Sweco” GmbH/Germany as sub-consultant and individualfor cultural heritage expertise |
Belgium & Albania/Germany |
11 |
JV. “Bernard Ingenieure ZT” GmbH& “Austria Rail Enginering(ARE)” GmbH&”G+A Projekt” sh.p.k |
Austria/Austria/Albania |
12 |
JV. “Studio Architettura Graziano Borghi”&”CEC Group” ltd & “AI.ERRE Engineering” s.r.l & “Mafin Green Power” s.r.l & “Sinnergie Soc. Cons.a.r.l.” & “Mobility in Chain (MIC) & & &Mobility in Chain |
Italy/Albania /Italy/Italy/Italy |
13 |
JV.”Ingegneri Riuniti” spa&”Rossi Prodi Associat” i &“Weissgerber & Partners”ltd |
Italy/Italy/Albania |
14 |
JV. “MBM arquitects” & “S.M.N. Studio di Architettura G.L. Sylos Labini e Partners S.S.T.P.” |
Spain/Italy |
15 |
“Anaplasi Consulting Engineers” s.a. & “Local Partner Edi Como Studio” |
Greece /Albania |
16 |
JV. “3TI Proggeti” s.p.a. & “ARS Progetti” s.p.a. & “Geosat Group” sh.p.k. |
Italy/Italy/Albania |
17 |
JV. “Ambiente”s.c &” Sferastudio”ltd &“Baukuh”& FM Ingenieria” |
Italy/Albania/Italy/Italy |
18 |
JV. “C+S Associati s.r.l” & “SON Engineering & Construction” & “Instituti I Politikave Private (IP3)” |
Italy/Albania/Albania |
19 |
“JV.Abkons ltd& “Arub Italia”srl |
Albania/Italy |
20 |
“Gaia S.A. Meleton |
Greece |
21 |
JV. “Bolles & Willson” GmbH & “Studio Schultz Granberg” GmbH & “Kemming Landschaftsarchitektur” &”Thomas&Boekamp IngenierurgesellschaftmbH” &”Giovanni Damiani”&
“Job Project” ltd |
Germany/Germany/Germany/ Italy/Albania |
22 |
JV.”Republic Institute for Urban Planning and Design” jsc &”Horwarth HTL”&”4 A-M” ltd |
Montenegro/Croatia /Albania |
23 |
“Gjekonsult & Co” |
Albania |
24 |
JV. “Studio 3piu1 Architetti Associati”&OOcra” srl &”Studio Archimed” sh.p.k. |
Italy/Italy/Albania |
25 |
“A & E Enginering” |
Albania |
26 |
JV. “Societa Italiana di Monitoraggio/ SIM” s.p.a&”SUT”srl |
Italy/Italy |
27 |
Association “Rogan Associates S.A & Betaplan S.A & Derbi-E l.t.d” |
Greece/Greece/Albania |
28 |
“Oikonomou & Associates” |
Greece |
29 |
Consorzio “Caire” |
Italy |
- Number of tender that has been shortlisted: 6
Association “IGH” d.d. & “Urban Planning Institute of Croatia” (UH) d.o.o. & “Taulant” ltd
Horwath HTL & Werner Bilgram
Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios”
Association “Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A. (TPA)” & “Arkostudio” ltd & “Erald” – G” ltd
Association “ABDR Architteti Associati” & “Metro Polis” ltd
Association “Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd
Association “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l. & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)” ltd
- Number of tenders that has submitted Request for Proposal: 6
Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios” – 94.28 points
Association “IGH” d.d. & “Urban Planning Institute of Croatia” (UH) d.o.o. & “Taulant” ltd
Horwath HTL & Werner Bilgram – 88.91 points
Association “Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A. (TPA)” & “Arkostudio” ltd & “Erald” – G” ltd – 86.10 points
Association “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l. & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)” ltd – 83.16 points
Association “ABDR Architteti Associati” & “Metro Polis” ltd – 83.12 points
Association “Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd – 75.47 points
- Financial prices as read out:
Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios” – 950,435 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “IGH” d.d. & “Urban Planning Institute of Croatia” (UH) d.o.o. & “Taulant” ltd
Horwath HTL & Werner Bilgram – 766,380 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A. (TPA)” & “Arkostudio” ltd & “Erald” – G” ltd – 1,074,282.79 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l. & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)” ltd – 1,160,150 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “ABDR Architteti Associati” & “Metro Polis” ltd – 958,333 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd – 987,106.57 Euro (VAT Excl)
- Financial prices after evaluation
Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios” – 950,435 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “IGH” d.d. & “Urban Planning Institute of Croatia” (UH) d.o.o. & “Taulant” ltd
Horwath HTL & Werner Bilgram – 766,380 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A. (TPA)” & “Arkostudio” ltd & “Erald” – G” ltd – 1,074,282.79 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l. & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)” ltd – 1,160,150 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “ABDR Architteti Associati” & “Metro Polis” ltd – 958,333 Euro (VAT Excl)
Association “Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd – 987,106.57 Euro (VAT Excl)
- The final combined score
| Technical Evaluation |
Financial Evaluation |
Combined Evaluation | |||||
| Consultants’ names | Technical scores S(t) |
Weighted scores S(t) ´ T |
Technical rank |
Financial scores S(f) |
Weighted scores S(f) ´ F |
Scores S(t) T + S(f) F |
Rank |
| Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios” | 94.28 | 75.42 | 1 | 80.63 | 16.13 | 91.55 | 1 |
| Association “IGH” d.d. & “Urban Planning Institute of Croatia” (UH) d.o.o. & “Taulant” ltd
Horwath HTL & Werner Bilgram |
88.91 | 71.13 | 2 | 100 | 20.00 | 91.13 | 2 |
| Association “Thymio Papayannis and Associates S.A. (TPA)” & “Arkostudio” ltd & “Erald” – G” ltd | 86.1 | 68.88 | 3 | 71.34 | 14.27 | 83.15 | 3 |
| Association “ABDR Architteti Associati” & “Metro Polis” ltd | 83.12 | 66.50 | 5 | 79.97 | 15.99 | 82.49 | 4 |
| Association “Open Plan Consulting” s.r.l. & “Planarch” s.r.l. & “Illyrian Consulting Engineers (ICE)” ltd | 83.16 | 66.53 | 4 | 66.06 | 13.21 | 79.74 | 5 |
| Association “Arep Ville” & “Suez Consulting” & “Dea Studio” ltd | 75.47 | 60.38 | 6 | 77.64 | 15.53 | 75.90 | 6 |
| To highest combined technical/financial score. Consultant’s name: Association “Atelier 4” (Albania) & “Keios” (Italy) |
|||||||
- Financial Offer of the chosen tenderer
950,435 (VAT Excl)
- Name, address and nationality of the successful tenderer
Association “Atelier 4” & “Keios”, Njesia Administrative Nr.5, Rr. “E Kosovareve”, Nd.35, Hyrja 6, Ap. 4/1, Tirana, Albania
